KLAWGURU.COM

Korean Law Demystified!

Korean Court Orders Damages After Truck Kills Pet Dog: Owner Awarded Emotional Distress Compensation

By ,

Court: Suwon District Court, Seongnam Branch
Decision Date: January 15, 2026
Case Type: Confirmation of Non-Existence of Debt / Damages

Key Ruling

  • A Korean court ruled that a vehicle insurer must compensate a dog owner after a pet was fatally injured in a traffic accident.
  • The court awarded:
    • Approximately 14.03 million KRW to the dog’s owner.
    • Approximately 24.53 million KRW to the pedestrian who was holding the dog at the time of the accident.
  • Notably, the court recognized emotional damages for the loss of a pet, awarding the owner 3 million KRW in consolation damages.

Facts of the Case

  • June 2021, around 8 PM
  • A truck driver (A) attempted a left turn at a three-way intersection in Hanam.
  • The driver failed to properly watch the road ahead.
  • The truck struck pedestrian D, who was crossing the street while carrying the dog belonging to owner C.

Consequences of the Accident

  • Pedestrian injuries
    • Knee contusion
    • Multiple fractures of the left ribs
    • Required hospitalization and outpatient treatment
  • Dog’s injuries
    • Pulmonary hemorrhage
    • Cerebellar herniation
    • Bowel dysfunction
    • Despite treatment, the dog died in July 2025.

Lawsuit

  • The insurance company (B) filed a lawsuit seeking a declaration that it had no further payment obligations.
  • The dog owner and injured pedestrian filed counterclaims seeking damages.

Court’s Findings

  • The court held that the accident occurred due to the driver’s failure to maintain proper lookout (전방주시의무 위반).
  • The insurer’s argument that the victims were partly at fault was rejected.
  • The court found no contributory negligence by the pedestrian or the dog owner.

Compensation Awarded

Dog Owner (C)

Recognized damages included:

  • Veterinary treatment costs: 9.16 million KRW
  • Supplies (including diapers): 1.62 million KRW
  • Funeral expenses: 250,000 KRW
  • Emotional distress (consolation damages): 3 million KRW

Total: ~14.03 million KRW

Injured Pedestrian (D)

Recognized damages included:

  • Lost income
  • Medical expenses
  • Consolation damages: 5 million KRW

Total: ~24.53 million KRW

Legal Significance

  • Korean courts traditionally treat pets as property under civil law.
  • However, this ruling shows courts increasingly recognizing emotional harm to pet owners when a companion animal is killed.
  • The decision also demonstrates that substantial veterinary expenses can be recoverable as property damage.

Article: https://www.lawtimes.co.kr/news/articleView.html?idxno=217438

Leave a comment