The Korean H-2 Visa (Working Visit): A Practical Guide
The Big Picture
1. Overview of the H-2 Visa
The H-2 (working visit) visa is a long-term residence status based on Article 10 of the Immigration Act and Article 12 [Attached Table 1] of its Enforcement Decree. It is a status that allows a foreign-nationality Korean (overseas Korean) to enter the Republic of Korea and engage in employment activity (Immigration Act, Article 10; Enforcement Decree of the Immigration Act, Article 12).
The principal beneficiaries are foreign-nationality Koreans from China, the former Soviet region, and the like (including Koryo-saram). It is distinguished from the F-4 (overseas Korean) visa in that employment is possible across a wide range of lines of work, including simple manual labor.
2. Specific Acquisition Requirements
A. Eligibility requirements for application
The principal eligibility requirements for the H-2 visa are as follows.
| Category | Content |
|---|---|
| Nationality | A foreign-nationality Korean (a person falling under Article 2, subparagraph 2 of the Act on the Immigration and Legal Status of Overseas Koreans) |
| Age | 18 years of age or older |
| Disqualifying grounds | Must have no criminal record, no record of forced removal, no record of unlawful overstay, etc. |
| Employment training | Completion of employment training after entry is required |
B. Period of stay
- Basic period of stay: 3 years (from the date of entry).
- Extendable period: an additional 1 year 10 months may be extended (a total maximum of 4 years 10 months).
- Re-entry: where the person departs after the period of stay expires, reapplication is possible after a certain period has elapsed (in principle 1 month; in the past, standards of 2 to 6 months have been applied in some cases), and there is no limit on the number of reissuances.
In practice, the courts have held that “the period of stay on a working visit (H-2) visa is in principle 3 years, but where an overseas Korean who had entered on working visit status departed normally within the period of stay, the person may apply for a re-entry visa one month after departure, and there is no limit on the number of times the visa may be reissued” (Jeonju District Court, Sept. 24, 2024, 2023gadan25850).
3. Documents to Prepare
A. Documents generally submitted when applying at an overseas mission
The following are the documents generally required in practice. That said, the required documents may differ according to Ministry of Justice guidelines and by overseas mission, so confirmation with the relevant mission before applying is essential.
| Document | Remarks |
|---|---|
| Visa issuance application form | Prescribed form |
| Passport | Validity of 6 months or more |
| Photograph | Standard-format photograph |
| Documents proving overseas-Korean status | Household register, removed household register, family relation certificate, etc. (proving prior Korean nationality or lineage) |
| Documents proving acquisition of foreign nationality | Foreign passport, certificate of nationality, etc. |
| Criminal record certificate | Issued by the country of residence |
| Health examination certificate | Required by some missions |
| Certificate of employment, income certificate, etc. | Where necessary |
B. Documents submitted when applying for an extension of the period of stay from within Korea
- Integrated application form
- Passport and alien registration card
- Employment contract or certificate of employment
- Standard employment contract (Ministry of Employment and Labor form)
- Copy of the business registration certificate
- Other documents required by the Ministry of Justice
Practical caution: Because the Administrative Procedures Act does not apply to matters relating to the Immigration Act, the administrative agency has no legal duty to request supplementation where the required documents are incomplete. The courts have held that “under Article 3(2), subparagraph 9 of the Administrative Procedures Act and Article 2, subparagraph 2 of its Enforcement Decree, the Administrative Procedures Act does not apply to matters relating to the entry and departure of foreigners, so even if the defendant did not go through the supplementation-request procedure under Article 17(5) of the Administrative Procedures Act before making the disposition at issue, it cannot be said that the disposition has a procedural defect” (Suwon District Court, Dec. 5, 2018, 2018gudan1583). It is therefore important to prepare the documents completely before applying.
4. Lines of Work Available for Employment, and the Scope
An H-2 visa holder may be employed across a wide range of lines of work, including simple manual labor, but the lines of work available for employment are designated by Ministry of Justice public notice. In practice, holders are employed mainly in construction, manufacturing, agriculture and livestock, the service sector, and the like.
However, employment in some lines of work, such as entertainment establishments, is restricted, and employment in a line of work that does not accord with the residence status constitutes a violation of the Immigration Act (see Daegu District Court, Apr. 15, 2016, 2015gojeong2879 — a case of employing an E-6 visa holder as an entertainment worker).
5. Key Precedents
A. Calculation of lost earnings — determining the period of possible employment in Korea
Where a foreign worker holding an H-2 visa suffers an industrial accident, the period of possible employment in Korea becomes the key issue in calculating lost earnings.
The basic legal principle has been stated as follows: “In calculating the lost earnings of a foreigner who is staying in the country temporarily and is expected to depart in the future, the lost earnings for the anticipated period of possible employment, or period of possible stay, in Korea should be calculated on the basis of income in Korea, and thereafter on the basis of the income obtainable in the country to which the foreigner is assumed to depart; the period of possible employment in Korea is appropriately recognized by taking into account factual and normative factors such as the purpose of and circumstances surrounding entry, the person’s own intent at the time of the accident, whether the person holds a residence status and its content, the period of stay, the record or likelihood of extensions of the period of stay, and the current state of employment” (Busan District Court, Dongbu Branch, Oct. 16, 2019, 2018gadan214410).
Determinations in specific cases:
- Where the period of possible employment was recognized: calculated on the Korean wage basis until the expiry date of the working visit (H-2) visa, and on the home-country wage basis thereafter (Incheon District Court, Bucheon Branch, May 28, 2020, 2019gadan16019; Jeonju District Court, Sept. 24, 2024, 2023gadan25850).
- Where the period of possible employment was not recognized: there is a case declining to recognize a period of possible employment in Korea after the visa’s expiry, holding that “the plaintiff suffered the accident at issue only about four months after entering the Republic of Korea, and there is no material recognizing that he had previously stayed in the Republic of Korea on a working visit visa (H-2) or had shown an intent to work in the Republic of Korea by, for example, applying for an extension of the period of stay; considering the age and family circumstances of the deceased C, it is also difficult to recognize the possibility that he would be employed in the Republic of Korea, repeating entries and departures every 3 years 6 months, until the end of his working life” (Incheon District Court, Feb. 20, 2018, 2016gadan248393).
- Where re-entry was impossible after forced deportation: the court held that where the person was in a state in which re-entry was impossible owing to forced deportation for theft, it is difficult to recognize a period of possible employment through reissuance of the H-2 visa (Suwon District Court, Ansan Branch, Jan. 16, 2020, 2018gadan55060).
B. The possibility of conversion to an F-4 (overseas Korean) visa
A foreign-nationality Korean who has worked for 2 years or more on an H-2 visa, or who is 60 years of age or older, may be issued an F-4 (overseas Korean) visa; the F-4 visa is renewable every 3 years with no limit on the number of renewals (Daejeon District Court, Cheonan Branch, July 24, 2019, 2017gadan112436). That said, one should note that conversion to an F-4 visa is straightforward only for those with little likelihood of engaging in simple manual labor—university graduates, representatives of corporate enterprises, holders of a craftsman-level or higher qualification, overseas Koreans aged 60 or older, and the like (Suwon District Court, Ansan Branch, July 13, 2016, 2014gadan39107).
The courts have also held that the possibility of conversion to F-4 must be proven by specific evidence, finding that “it is insufficient to recognize that, had the accident at issue not occurred, the person could have acquired an overseas Korean visa (F-4) and continued to stay in our country even after the expiry date of the working visit visa (H-2)” (Seoul Central District Court, Apr. 17, 2015, 2014gahap505173).
C. Acquiring a visa by improper means — criminal punishment
Acquiring or brokering a visa by improper means, such as a false letter of invitation, is subject to criminal punishment for violating the Immigration Act (Seoul Eastern District Court, Apr. 7, 2021, 2020godan4298 (severed) — brokering acquisition of a short-term visit (C-3) visa with a false letter of invitation; 6 months’ imprisonment, suspended for 2 years).
6. Key Points to Note After Acquisition
A. Complying with employment within the scope of the residence status
An H-2 visa holder may be employed only within the lines of work available for employment designated by Ministry of Justice public notice. A person who engages in activity outside the scope of the residence status may be subject to forced removal and criminal punishment for violating the Immigration Act.
B. Observing the period of stay and applying for extensions
An extension must be applied for before the period of stay expires; unlawful overstay can result in forced removal and a re-entry ban. A record of unlawful overstay also becomes a serious obstacle to subsequent visa reissuance.
C. Prohibition on criminal conduct
Criminal punishment arising from criminal conduct (especially theft, violence, etc.) can lead to forced removal and a re-entry ban, in which case reissuance of the H-2 visa becomes effectively impossible (see Suwon District Court, Ansan Branch, Jan. 16, 2020, 2018gadan55060).
D. Confirming whether the requirements for conversion to an F-4 visa are met
Where the person has engaged in employment activity for 2 years or more on an H-2 visa, conversion to an F-4 visa may be considered; the F-4 visa has restrictions on simple manual labor but offers greater stability of stay. It is important to confirm in advance whether the conversion requirements are met.
E. Prohibition on submitting improper documents
Submitting forged or altered documents, or documents containing false facts, when applying for a change or extension of residence status is subject to criminal punishment for violating the Immigration Act (Seoul Western District Court, Jan. 10, 2024, 2023godan2544; Seoul Western District Court, July 7, 2022, 2022godan653; and others).
Converting from H-2 (Working Visit) to F-4 (Overseas Korean) Status: A Practical Guide
1. The Legal Basis of F-4 Status
The F-4 (overseas Korean) residence status is based on Article 5(1) of the Act on the Immigration and Legal Status of Overseas Koreans (hereinafter the “Overseas Koreans Act”). That provision states that “the Minister of Justice may, upon application, grant overseas Korean residence status to a foreign-nationality Korean who wishes to engage in activity within the Republic of Korea” (Overseas Koreans Act, Article 5(1)), and its acquisition requirements and scope of activity are delegated to Presidential Decree (Enforcement Decree of the Immigration Act, Article 12 [Attached Table 1-2]) (Overseas Koreans Act, Article 5(4); Enforcement Decree of the Immigration Act, Article 12).
The Constitutional Court has held that delegating the acquisition requirements of the overseas Korean residence status to Presidential Decree does not violate the principle of statutory reservation (Constitutional Court, Apr. 24, 2014, 2012heonba412).
2. Requirements for Conversion from H-2 to F-4
A. Basic requirement — status as a foreign-nationality Korean
The most basic requirement for conversion to F-4 status is that the person fall within the definition of a foreign-nationality Korean under Article 2, subparagraph 2 of the Overseas Koreans Act. That is, the person must be one who once held the nationality of the Republic of Korea, or a lineal descendant of such a person, who has acquired a foreign nationality, and who is among those prescribed by Presidential Decree.
Because an H-2 visa holder was already granted working visit status on the premise of being a foreign-nationality Korean, this requirement is usually satisfied. That said, for some, such as Koryo-saram, the authenticity of the documents proving overseas-Korean status may be at issue.
B. The requirement of being a person with a low likelihood of engaging in simple manual labor (key)
Because F-4 status restricts simple manual labor, the Ministry of Justice takes the approach of granting F-4 status only to persons with a low likelihood of engaging in simple manual labor. The courts have held on this point as follows.
“The Ministry of Justice has a policy of issuing F-4 visas only to those with little likelihood of engaging in simple manual labor—university graduates, representatives of corporate enterprises, holders of a craftsman-level or higher qualification, overseas Koreans aged 60 or older, and the like” (Suwon District Court, Ansan Branch, July 13, 2016, 2014gadan39107).
The courts have also held that “a foreign-nationality Korean who has worked for 2 years or more on an H-2 visa, or who is 60 years of age or older, may be issued an F-4 visa; the F-4 visa is renewable every 3 years with no limit on the number of renewals” (Daejeon District Court, Cheonan Branch, July 24, 2019, 2017gadan112436).
The principal types under which F-4 conversion is recognized in practice may be summarized as follows.
| Type | Content |
|---|---|
| Educational | University graduate (including junior college) |
| Occupation / qualification | Holder of a national technical qualification at craftsman level or above; representative of a corporate enterprise |
| Age | 60 years of age or older |
| Employment record | Employment activity for 2 years or more on H-2 status |
Caution: The above requirements follow internal Ministry of Justice policy, and because Ministry of Justice public notices and guidelines may change from time to time, the latest guidelines as of the time of application must be confirmed.
C. Absence of disqualifying grounds
Article 5(2) of the Overseas Koreans Act provides that F-4 status is not to be granted where any of the following grounds applies.
| Disqualifying ground | Content |
|---|---|
| Renunciation/loss of nationality to evade military service | A man who renounced or lost nationality without having completed service such as active duty or supplementary service (however, from January 1 of the year he turns 41, status may be granted at the discretion of the Minister of Justice) |
| Concern of harm to the interests of the Republic of Korea | Where there is a concern of harm to the interests of the Republic of Korea, such as national security, the maintenance of order, public welfare, or foreign relations |
3. Application Procedure
A. Applying for a change of status from within Korea
A foreign-nationality Korean who is staying in Korea on an H-2 visa may apply for permission to change residence status from within Korea, without departing. Under Article 12 [Attached Table 1-2] of the Enforcement Decree of the Immigration Act, a foreign-nationality Korean who has already entered and is staying on another residence status must apply for permission to change residence status (see Daejeon District Court, Sept. 16, 2021, 2020gudan1037).
B. Principal documents to submit
The following are the documents generally required in practice. The required documents may differ according to the competent immigration office, so confirmation in advance is necessary.
| Document | Remarks |
|---|---|
| Integrated application form | Prescribed form |
| Passport and alien registration card | Originals |
| Documents proving overseas-Korean status | Household register, removed household register, birth certificate, family relation certificate, etc. (proving prior Korean nationality or lineage) |
| Educational certificates | Graduation certificate, etc. (where the educational requirement applies) |
| National technical qualification | Craftsman level or above (where the qualification requirement applies) |
| Certificate of employment / business registration certificate | Where the person is a representative of a corporate enterprise |
| Documents proving employment record | Where proving employment activity for 2 years or more on H-2 status |
| Criminal record certificate | Where necessary |
Practical caution: The authenticity of the documents proving overseas-Korean status is key. There is a case in which the court held unlawful a disposition denying a change to F-4 status on the ground that a Russian-national Koryo-saram had submitted a birth certificate but it lacked apostille certification and the authenticity of the document could not be confirmed (Daejeon District Court, Sept. 16, 2021, 2020gudan1037). Securing the authenticity of documents (apostille certification or consular certification by an overseas mission) is therefore very important.
C. Whether the Administrative Procedures Act applies
Because the Administrative Procedures Act does not apply to matters relating to the entry and departure of foreigners, the administrative agency has no legal duty to request supplementation where the required documents are incomplete. It is therefore very important in practice to prepare the documents completely before applying.
That said, because the Supreme Court has held that, in the case of a visa-refusal disposition, the requirement of a written disposition under Article 24(1) of the Administrative Procedures Act applies (Supreme Court, July 11, 2019, 2017du38874), a procedural defect as to the form of the disposition may still be at issue.
4. Grounds for Refusing Conversion, and Key Precedents
A. Criminal record
A criminal record is the most frequent ground for refusing a change to F-4 status. The courts have held as follows.
- Three drunk-driving offenses: where the person was punished three times for violating the Road Traffic Act (drunk driving), the court held lawful the cancellation of F-4 permission and the departure order (Suwon District Court, Sept. 11, 2024, 2024gudan10397).
- Refusal of a breathalyzer test: where the person was sentenced to a fine of KRW 5 million for violating the Road Traffic Act (refusal of a breathalyzer test), the court held the departure order lawful (Jeonju District Court, Nov. 25, 2021, 2021guhap2084).
- Marijuana use: where the person was sentenced to 6 months’ imprisonment, suspended for 1 year, for marijuana use, the court held the departure order lawful (Seoul Administrative Court, Apr. 23, 2021, 2019gudan66029).
- Violation of the Act on Special Cases Concerning the Settlement of Traffic Accidents: where the person was sentenced to 8 months’ imprisonment without labor, suspended for 2 years, the court held the departure order lawful (Seoul High Court, Apr. 3, 2019, 2018nu71375).
- Sexual offense: where the person received a summary order for indecent act by force, the court held the departure order lawful (Seoul Administrative Court, Apr. 3, 2015, 2014guhap56161).
That said, even where there is a criminal record, the courts examine whether there was an exceeding or abuse of discretion under the principle of proportionality. For example, there is a case holding that issuing a departure order—on the basis of an application for permanent residence (F-5) status, where F-4 status had already been granted despite a past criminal record—exceeded and abused discretion (Uijeongbu District Court, June 1, 2016, 2015gudan5519).
B. Identity mismatch (record of entry under another’s name)
Where there is a record of entry under another person’s name, a change to F-4 status may be refused. The court held lawful a forced-removal order where a person who had entered under another’s name and been forcibly removed, then re-entered under his own name and acquired F-4 status, was later found to have an identity mismatch (Seoul Administrative Court, Nov. 20, 2018, 2018gudan56391; Incheon District Court, Aug. 21, 2018, 2018gudan50045).
C. Submission of false documents
Where F-4 status was acquired by submitting forged or altered documents, such as a false household register (hukou), the extension of the period of stay may be denied and a departure order issued (Daejeon District Court, Dec. 24, 2020, 2020gudan101517).
D. Renunciation of nationality to evade military service
Where the person acquired a foreign nationality to evade military service, F-4 status is refused. The Supreme Court has held that, even in this case, where the agency refuses a visa while exercising no discretion at all and being bound solely by an entry-ban decision, whether this violates the principle of proportionality must be examined (Supreme Court, July 11, 2019, 2017du38874).
E. Inability to prove overseas-Korean status
There is a case at issue in which a change to F-4 status was denied on the ground that a birth certificate listing both parents as Buryat alone made it difficult to prove status as a lineal descendant of an overseas Korean. The court judged the lawfulness of the disposition according to the specific circumstances (Daejeon District Court, Sept. 16, 2021, 2020gudan1037).
F. Record of unlawful overstay
A record of unlawful overstay works unfavorably in the grant of F-4 status. That said, even where there is a record of unlawful overstay, the outcome may differ according to the specific circumstances—for example, where the person subsequently acquired residence status lawfully and lived diligently (see Seoul Administrative Court, Apr. 21, 2016, 2015guhap4112).
5. Points to Note After Conversion
A. Restriction on simple manual labor
A holder of F-4 status is restricted from simple manual labor. Unlike the H-2 visa, simple-manual-labor employment is not permitted, so after conversion the lines of work available for employment must be confirmed.
B. Renewal of the period of stay
F-4 status is renewable every 3 years with no limit on the number of renewals (Daejeon District Court, Cheonan Branch, July 24, 2019, 2017gadan112436). That said, the requirements—such as the absence of disqualifying grounds—must also be satisfied at renewal.
C. Prohibition on criminal conduct
Even after acquiring F-4 status, criminal conduct is a ground for cancellation of residence permission and for a departure order or forced removal. Drunk driving, drugs, and sexual offenses, in particular, are dealt with strictly.
D. Challenging a visa-refusal disposition
Where a change to F-4 status is refused, a foreign-nationality Korean is recognized as having the right to apply for an overseas Korean visa under the Overseas Koreans Act, and so has a legal interest in seeking revocation of the refusal disposition (Seoul Administrative Court, June 19, 2024, 2023gudan77064). A refusal disposition may therefore be challenged through an administrative appeal or an administrative suit.
Thank you for reading! For questions and comments: klawguru@gmail.com
KLAWGURU.COM 
Leave a comment