Korean Law Demystified!

Playing in Japan, Paying Taxes in Korea: Supreme Court Confirms Kim Young-gwon’s Tax Residency

Korean football star Kim Young-gwon, who played for Japanese professional clubs from 2019 to 2021, has lost his challenge against a tax assessment of approximately ₩830 million — with the Supreme Court confirming that he remained a Korean tax resident throughout that period and owed comprehensive income tax in Korea on his Japanese earnings. Here are the key points.


Background

  • Kim played for Chinese professional clubs from 2012 to 2018, paying taxes locally in China. He moved to Japan in 2019 and played there until 2021, before returning to a Korean club in 2022.
  • During his China years, Kim paid foreign taxes exceeding the available domestic foreign tax credit limit. Approximately ₩600 million of those Chinese taxes could not be credited against his Korean tax liability at the time they were paid.
  • When filing his Korean comprehensive income tax returns for 2019 to 2021 — his Japan years — Kim sought to deduct not only the taxes he had paid in Japan, but also the ₩600 million in previously uncredited Chinese taxes.
  • Ulsan Tax Office rejected the additional deduction, recalculated the credit, and issued a supplementary assessment of approximately ₩830 million in comprehensive income tax for 2019 to 2021.
  • Kim filed suit arguing he was not a Korean tax resident during the Japan years and therefore owed no Korean comprehensive income tax for that period.

The Two Issues

Issue 1: Was Kim a Korean tax resident during 2019–2021?

  • Kim’s family maintained their life in Korea throughout. Kim transferred most of his Japanese earnings to Korea or spent them there. He lived with his family in a Seoul apartment. He also operated a business and rental property in Korea.
  • All three courts — trial, appellate, and Supreme Court — found that Korea was the country with which Kim had the closer connection, making him a Korean tax resident under the tax code. As a resident, he was obligated to file Korean comprehensive income tax on his worldwide income, including his Japanese earnings.

Issue 2: Can the uncredited Chinese taxes be applied against Korean tax on Japanese income?

  • Unused foreign tax credits from one year can in principle be carried forward to subsequent years. However, the Supreme Court confirmed they can only be applied against Korean tax attributable to income from the same source country. The uncredited Chinese taxes cannot be used to offset Korean tax on income earned in Japan — the two are separate foreign income streams with separate credit calculations.

Court Decision

  • The Supreme Court (Special Division 3, presiding Justice Oh Seok-jun) dismissed Kim’s appeal on September 23, 2026, confirming the ₩830 million assessment.

Key Takeaways

  • Korean tax residency is determined by the substance of a person’s life connections — where family lives, where income is sent and used, where property and business interests are held — not by where the person is physically present for work. Playing abroad does not by itself make an athlete a non-resident for Korean tax purposes.
  • Foreign professional athletes who maintain their family home, financial activity, and business interests in Korea while working overseas are likely to be treated as Korean tax residents, with worldwide income subject to Korean comprehensive income tax.
  • Foreign tax credit carryforwards are country-specific. Unused credits from one foreign country cannot be applied against Korean tax on income earned in a different country in a later year.
  • The combination of these two findings — resident status plus country-specific credit limitation — produced the ₩830 million assessment that all three courts upheld.

Why This Matters

For Korean athletes and professionals working abroad, this ruling is a clear signal that maintaining substantial life connections in Korea — family residence, financial flows, business operations — will result in Korean tax residency regardless of where work is physically performed. The decision also clarifies a technical but important point about foreign tax credit mechanics: the carryforward of unused credits is available, but the credits remain tied to the source country that generated them and cannot be repurposed against income from other countries. For tax practitioners advising clients with multi-country careers, the case reinforces the importance of genuinely restructuring life connections — not just changing workplace location — when seeking to establish non-resident status.

Article: https://www.lawtimes.co.kr/news/articleView.html?idxno=227861

Leave a Reply